Canada needs more competition. On that, there is something close to an economic consensus. The OECD, IMF (Page 22) and Bank of Canada have all made the case that stronger competition and business dynamism are essential to lifting productivity. Higher productivity, in turn, is key to making life more affordable.

Ottawa has already started to act on this logic, strengthening federal competition laws with unusually broad support across the ideological spectrum.

But much of the work that remains lies elsewhere – in the technical, decidedly unglamorous rules scattered across levels of government. Think internal trade barriers, procurement frameworks, occupational licensing requirements and outdated or unnecessary regulation.

Opening markets to competition will sometimes mean removing or amending existing rules and sometimes adding new ones. Each reform runs into a different set of interests. Without a unifying frame, the common thread can easily get lost.

We need a better way to think and talk about pro-competitive reform. Perhaps there is an old phrase worth bringing back: planning for competition.

Friedrich Hayek used the phrase in the 1940s to distinguish government planning that keeps markets open, competitive and adaptable from planning that tries to fix outcomes.

That’s what Canada needs today.

Terminology matters

Consider open banking, now being implemented as “consumer-driven banking.” It took the better part of a decade for Canada to catch up with a reform already adopted elsewhere amid concerns about privacy and security.

Those concerns needed answers, but the branding of the reform didn’t help. “Open banking” led people to think their financial information would be out in the open. The shift in wording to “consumer-driven banking” helped clarify that the reform was actually about giving consumers safer control over their data and more power to make providers compete for their business.

One Canadian economy needs one competition policy

When Canadian regulations favour corporate concentration

The Competition Act favoured concentration from the start

Labels can mislead in the other direction, too. When burdensome regulation makes it harder for new businesses to enter markets and grow, the answer may involve “deregulation” or “liberalization” or “red tape reduction.”

But those labels can carry political baggage.

For instance, the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives says the recent push to ease internal trade barriers risks being a “Trojan Horse for deregulation” backed by corporate Canada.

From the opposite direction, in 2023, the Fraser Institute criticized Ontario’s package of worker-focused regulations, including its non-compete ban, as government “dictating the terms of employment arrangements.”

Labels can confuse

But neither the spectre of deregulation nor the spectre of government intervention tells us whether a reform is good or bad.

The problem is that these labels invite us to choose sides before considering what a reform actually does. The politics rarely line up as neatly as the labels imply.

It was Doug Ford’s Progressive Conservative government that banned non-competes – a move the federal government has since proposed extending (Part 4) to the federally regulated workforce.

In New York, Mayor Zohran Mamdani has made “government efficiency” and “slashing red tape” sound progressive, through the cheekily named “COGE” and more than 50 small business reforms.

It can sometimes be easier for governments to pursue reforms that run counter to ideological expectations. But political permission is a poor substitute for a shared language of reform.

Talk of easing regulatory barriers can elicit an understandable fear among progressives that important protections are about to disappear. Stronger protections for consumers or workers can provoke a different anxiety among market-oriented audiences that policymakers are drifting toward too much government intervention.

Planning for competition

Yet, most experts agree that some economic planning is unavoidable. Markets depend on rules that shape who can enter, compete and grow. The challenge is that different kinds of planning make different groups antsy.

That’s where planning for competition comes in.

The premise is one of humility. We can’t know in advance where the best ideas, technologies or business models will originate. Therefore, it’s better to adopt rules that keep markets broadly open to participation, leaving room for experimentation, discovery and change.

Very different political traditions can arrive at the same basic idea.

A worldwide trend

The Biden administration adopted a whole-of-government competition agenda built around 72 initiatives across more than a dozen U.S. federal agencies. Some called for new government intervention while others focused on removing barriers or loosening existing rules. The common aim was more open and competitive markets.

Australia’s revitalized national competition policy follows the same logic across diverse policy areas such as zoning, occupational licensing and worker mobility.

Planning for competition is a positive agenda. It focuses attention on what we are trying to build: markets where consumers can switch, workers can move and in the words of Canadian Nobel laureate Peter Howitt, “young upstarts” can get a foothold in established industries. It represents an inclusive vision for how markets should work.

The federal government deserves credit for starting to plan this way.

Its November 2026 budget advances a whole-of-government competition plan (Section 1.5) explicitly casting government as a “driver of competition” and calling for “competition by default” in federal decision-making. The plan would apply a competition lens not only to regulation, but also to procurement, cabinet and budget decisions, and federal business support programs.

That would build on a growing set of pro-competitive reforms underway in areas such as telecom, financial services and food.

International experience shows this competition lens can sit comfortably alongside and be part of the solution for other public goals, such as health, safety, national security and environmental protection.

Governments cannot explain every technical rule change one by one. But they can explain what they are trying to build, how priorities are being identified and why the exercise is neither an indiscriminate assault on regulation nor a licence to micromanage the economy.

As governments take a more active role in markets, they should expect to be asked whether they are opening up opportunities or simply picking winners.

Regulation versus deregulation, big government versus small, industrial policy versus laissez-faire. Those are all poor guides. The better question is what kind of economy our policy choices are helping to create.

The point is not to plan more or to plan less. It is to plan for competition.

The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not represent any policies or positions of the Competition Bureau or the federal government.

Do you have something to say about the article you just read? Be part of the Policy Options discussion, and send in your own submission. Here is a link on how to do it.

You are welcome to republish this Policy Options article online or in print periodicals, under a Creative Commons/No Derivatives licence. Photographs cannot be republished.

Matthew Chiasson photo

Matthew Chiasson

Matthew Chiasson is a J.W. McConnell Visiting Scholar at McGill University’s Max Bell School of Public Policy and a senior policy adviser at the federal Competition Bureau.

Luis De la Melena photo

Luis De la Melena

Luis De la Melena is a master of public policy candidate at McGill University’s Max Bell School of Public Policy, with a background in political philosophy and technology startups.

Related Stories